The Phillies made a couple of unheralded Rule 5 picks during the off-season, selecting pitcher Andy Oliver from the Pittsburgh Pirates and outfielder Odubel Herrera from the Rangers. Oliver showed some good swing-and-miss stuff, but faltered with his control and the Phillies wanted to send him to Triple-A Lehigh Valley rather than keep him on the major league roster. As was his right, Oliver elected to attempt to find work elsewhere, a decision that drew the ire of GM Ruben Amaro, Jr. and made headlines. Herrera was mostly forgotten about.
In early March, not knowing too much about the guy, I suggested Herrera could be “dynamic” for the Phillies. It didn’t appear that would be the case, as Herrera ended May with a .249 average and a .635 OPS while looking uncomfortable in center field.