2017 Phillies Report Card: Joaquin Benoit

The 2016 Phillies had the 3rd worst bullpen ERA in baseball at 5.05. The Phillies entered the offseason looking to provide some stability to the late innings and signed Joaquin Benoit to go along with earlier acquisition Pat Neshek.

Whereas Neshek was coming off a subpar year, Benoit had just gotten off a great end of the year with the Blue Jays (23.2 IP 0.38 ERA) after coming over in a trade from Seattle. More than just trying to build on a hot end of year, Benoit truly represented some stability for the Phillies. From 2010 to 2016, Benoit pitched in 439 games (427.0 IP) with a 2.40 ERA and a 3.23 FIP. Despite some time as a closer with Detroit and San Diego, Benoit had developed a reputation as a solid 8th inning reliever. Thanks to an ill advised decision to have Jeanmar Gomez open as the closer, Benoit opened as a 6th/7th inning arm for the Phillies.

After Gomez lost the closer’s job, Benoit was promoted past Hector Neris into the closer’s role. After a successful save on April 15, Benoit allowed Bryce Harper to murder a baseball:

He was promptly banished back to the 8th inning, where he rattled off 7 straight scoreless appearances before blowing a game in the 8th to the Cubs. Then on May 10th against the Mariners he did this:

  • Single
  • Walk
  • Double (1 run scores)
  • Flyball
  • IBB
  • Double (3 runs score)

Edubray Ramos would bring that last run home, bringing the total to 5 runs. Benoit then continued a pattern of looking competent with 8 scoreless outings before landing on the DL with a left knee injury. After returning from the DL, Benoit blew another game in June and lost two more in July, bringing him into the trade deadline at:

44 G, 42.0 IP,  1-4, 3 BS, 4.07 ERA

Benoit’s ERA and FIP were better than the full experience felt. He had contributed directly to 6 losses and a lot more innings that felt like pending losses. The fanbase was ready to cut him.

And Klentak managed to trade him.

The Phillies ate money on the remaining part of his $7.5M contract and sent him to Pittsburgh for minor league reliever Seth McGarry. McGarry would have it rough down the stretch for Clearwater, and right now does not look like anything special, but Benoit was gone.

Grade: C-

Benoit’s numbers were better than the experience felt. His contributions to destabilizing the bullpen and digging the Phillies into a deep hole might have earned him an D- or F had he stayed in Philly the whole year. However, he was traded, and that allows us to look at his season a bit more objectively. Also, he gets a slight bump because it is funny that he ended up on the Pirates roster at the end of the year and the Phillies got Juan Nicasio for free.

Leave a Reply


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


  1. Mike Fassano

    October 03, 2017 08:21 PM

    Matt, help me out here. I’ve posted several times that the Phillies should target Michael Fulmer. I see him on about the same level as Aaron Nola. Other posters are telling me that he’s a physical wreck, and that he’s had major surgery. From what I’m told, it’s the same surgery that Velasquez had. Does that mean that Velasquez is also a physical wreck? As far as I know both pitchers are expected to be ready for Spring training. Has something changed that I haven’t heard about?

    • Eddie

      October 04, 2017 06:22 AM

      “Other posters are telling me…”

      There’s your trouble.

      • Mike Fassano

        October 04, 2017 10:16 AM

        It’s very strange in that every person I’ve spoken with knows somebody whose life is changed forever.

    • Matt Winkelman

      October 04, 2017 09:35 AM

      Fulmer’s injury is never related, but more serious than Velasquez, but even if it was, this is not his first elbow injury (just like Velasquez who is an injury concern). Plus you have the cost. Giving Velasquez another chance to start costs the Phillies very little. The Tigers have little motivation or need to sell Fulmer for anything but peak value. That means he would probably cost 2 of Sixto Sanchez, J.P. Crawford, and Scott Kingery. With his injury risk, is it a sound investment to push your top chips in on Fulmer, almost certainly not.

      • Mike Fassano

        October 04, 2017 10:14 AM

        Thanks, and go screw yourself Tigers. Maybe Archer or Stroman.

Next Article2017 Phillies Report Card: Jerad Eickhoff