Phillies Trade Pat Neshek, Now What?

Last night the Phillies shipped their best relief pitcher out of town for a trio of prospects that won’t be helping the Phillies any time soon. I wrote about those prospects here so I don’t want to just write the same thing here. Instead the Phillies are now down their best relief pitcher right when the team was starting to shown some signs of life. Additionally, after there was a road map for what a trade like this might return, the Phillies opted to go for a completely different route in what they got back from the Rockies.

To start with the second part first. It was no secret that the Phillies were looking for players without 40 man roster implications in trades. The Phillies are going to open up some 40 man roster spots this winter, but the emergence of Jesen Therrien and Yacksel Rios, coupled with Carlos Tocci’s breakthrough have complicated an already tight Rule 5 protection list. The Phillies were never going to get a real impact player for Pat Neshek, he is almost 37 years old and an upcoming free agent. While he is having a career year, his track record over 11 major league seasons is that he is more of a 6th/7th inning reliever than the lights out guy he has been so far. It also further complciates things for a contender that he is limited to one inning stints and there was some controversy about his ability to go multiple days in a row. So that leaves the Phillies with a couple of choices in trade return. You either get a high minors player with a marginal ceiling (like the White Sox did in the Anthony Swarzak trade). The only problem is that most high minors players that aren’t elite are either on a 40 man roster or will need to be this offseason. That means the Phillies had to look more towards the low minors. They got 3 guys with ceilings about where I would have expected them to get in a high minors player, but by the nature of them being in A-ball, they are both lower ranked and much riskier. The upside is that the only player eligible for the Rule 5 draft is Jose Gomez, and as an A-ball middle infielder he is not in danger given his lack of elite tools. This allows the Phillies to get the same kind of return and protect an extra player this winter.

As for what the Phillies do now, they functionally have two bullpen holes. One is occupied by Jake Thompson, who was called up for Ricardo Pinto after Monday’s disastrous game. Thompson is still being used as a starter in AAA, so I would expect to see him go back down to the minors today or tomorrow. Ricardo Pinto can’t be called back up for another 7 days, so the Phillies will need to look in another direction. One of the spots probably goes to Edubray Ramos, who has been solid, but unspectacular, in his attempts to get his season back on track (Update: Edubray Ramos went on the DL with a blister this afternoon). The other spot is more interesting because the Phillies are out of 40 man relievers. They could turn to a starter like Mark Leiter to be a swing man, or they could call up Jesen Therrien. As was referenced earlier, Therrien is a future minor league free agent who the Phillies would have needed to add to the 40 man roster this offseason to keep. He has had a breakout year this season, showing both a bit more velocity and a slider that looks like it could be an out pitch. Even with 2 walks last night, Therrien has 9 walks to 65 strikeouts in 57.1 innings across AA and AAA. Therrien doesn’t profile as a late innings reliever, and it would be asking a lot for him to replace Neshek’s production. However, he could be a solid piece of the bullpen going forward and it will be interesting see what he can do in a major league audition.

Now we wait to see if the Phillies can move Howie Kendrick or Jeremy Hellickson in the next few days before we have to repeat all of this during August.

Leave a Reply


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


  1. Romus

    July 27, 2017 01:34 PM

    Perhaps Hammer will turn into a reliever somewhat akin to a Giles type reliever….or better yet a poor-mans version of Brad Lidge of ’08, but not ’09.
    If he can harness that slider with consistency there is that outside chance.

    • Shane

      July 29, 2017 10:00 AM

      Hammer could always add a change-up. Fastball, Slider, Change-up is a good mix. Especially if the Change tails in the opposite direction of the Slider. In the past, the Phillies development system has done well with developing Change-ups (Hamels, Madson, and they taught Halliday his change).

  2. Jim Shorts

    July 27, 2017 02:40 PM

    Thanks for this article, it’s really good insight as to why they targeted the type of players they did.

    I guess this cycle will continue while they are still no where near contending. Sign free agents in the offseason in the hopes that they will yield trade value come deadline. Basically spend $ for lottery tickets. Hopefully some of these scratch offs pan out.

    • Mike Fassano

      July 27, 2017 03:11 PM

      I’d be surprised and disappointed if the Phillies spend for more “lottery tickets” this winter. I got killed for saying this on another Phillies site, but I don’t think that the Phillies are as far away as many of you think. They have the worst record in baseball, but I don’t think they are the least talented team. The starting pitchers have taken their lumps this year, but it’s a learning process. If the Phillies can add a starter with Nola’s age and ability over the winter either through Free Agency or by trading a player and a prospect or two, so be it. The more innings that we can get out of the rotation, the better off the bullpen will be.
      Another area that the Front Office must address is the management of the team. They need to go outside of the organization, and hire a manager who doesn’t go strictly by the baseball book. They need to let him pick his own staff and not shove the current coaches down his throat.

    • Eddie

      July 27, 2017 09:11 PM

      I kind of think they’re now moving past the “bring in the rental vets stage,” just because by next year, at every single position they have a young guy that will be needing MLB at bats. Maybe they bring in one experienced starter and another in the bullpen who can be flipped, but other than that, it’s gonna be kids all over the diamond (or else a veteran they bring in to be a medium-term core piece, e.g. Yelich, Lance Lynn)

  3. Mike Fassano

    July 27, 2017 02:42 PM

    I was kind of hoping that they could pair up Neshek and Tirado and subtract two from the 40 man roster.

  4. denzen

    July 29, 2017 03:05 AM

    That seems like old news.

Next ArticleCrash Bag Vol. 30: The Next Great Phillies Team