Phillies’ Patience Allows for Joseph Turnaround

Rhys Hoskins is hitting .327/.407/.617 in AAA. He is putting up one of the best hitting seasons in the minor leagues. On May 1, the Phillies biggest weaknesses were probably catcher and first base. This led to calls for Hoskins (and Jorge Alfaro) to be promoted to the major leagues. Since the beginning of May, Cameron Rupp has been hitting .364/.462/.636, but more importantly, Tommy Joseph is hitting .393/.500/.857. Even with this surge, Joseph has been a below average hitter on the year, but it begins to reopen the debate on who is the first baseman of the future and how should that battle play out.

Last year, Joseph was almost assuredly the biggest surprise for the Phillies. He was on the edge of being released from the organization, and he hadn’t received an invite to major league camp. Despite all of that, he ended up hitting .257/.308/.505 for the Phillies, and was even better from July 1 until the end of the season, when he hit .281/.355/.546 with a 9.0% walk rate and a 19.0% strikeout rate. For that 3 month stretch, he was a Top 15 first baseman in baseball. We also can’t go into why Joseph has been good of late without addressing how bad he was to start the year.

Sometimes it is hard to find the underlying statistical difference that drives results, sometimes it is really easy. From 2016 to 2017, Tommy Joseph swung at roughly the same number of pitches in and out of the zone. The problem is that he is only making contact on 70.7% of those swings, down from 78.1% last season (league average is 77.6%). When he did make contact, he made poor contact, with his ground ball and fly ball rates experiencing a 10 point swing. Additionally, he started hitting infield fly balls at a greatly increased rate. In other words, Joseph looked bad in person, and his stats looked bad on the sheet.

So why is Joseph suddenly good now? Part of it is small sample size and pitcher mix. In April, Joseph had 52 plate appearances vs RHPS and 20 plate appearances vs LHPs. In May, that mix is 23 to 11. Joseph also didn’t hit LHPs well in April, and in 11 PAs in May he has 3 walks, 3 strikeouts, 3 home runs, and a double. But it isn’t just facing LHPs, because Joseph’s OPS vs RHPS is up over 300 points. He is striking out less, and he is walking more. Fangraph’s monthly splits also have him at a 40% line drive rate in May, up from 8.3% in April, and his ground ball rate has dropped 24 points.

Those are all small samples, and in reality this is a hot streak for Joseph. It just happens to be one that is offsetting a terrible start. Joseph is still striking out too much, especially if his ISO is below .200 (only .189 right now). However, what we are seeing in May is why the Phillies have been hesitant to commit to pushing Hoskins to the majors and casting Joseph aside. Hoskins may well be the better option down the line for the Phillies, but the change from Joseph to Hoskins may not be a big improvement for the 2017 Phillies, and they (and other teams) still have more to learn about Tommy Joseph.

As the Phillies look to integrate in prospects over the coming year, this situation is likely to play out at other positions as well. It is easy to say that a player is done after a few weeks, but front offices are thinking in the long term, and they are not going to give up on players quickly. For now, Joseph is the Phillies’ first baseman, whether he keeps that role going forward or not. By being patient, the Phillies gave him the time to turn things around and put the organization in a better situation.

Leave a Reply


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


  1. Mike Fassano

    May 11, 2017 01:31 PM

    I agree with you 100%. Normally, I’m a bring the kids up and let them learn on the job guy, but Joseph and Rupp are both relatively young too. Having said all of that, I believe that Rupp is killing us behind the plate. He’d make a perfect DH, backup catcher on an American league team. Rather than bring up Alfaro at this point, I’d bring up the best defensive catcher in the system.

    • Anthony

      May 11, 2017 01:59 PM

      I believe Rupp is not the long term answer at catcher. With that being said, I’ve read that his pitch calling is questionable and I’m curious if we had a better pitch caller and a better framer, would that benefit our younger guys in the rotation? Not only now, but long term. Basically, is Rupp hurting the development of our younger pitchers?

      • Supra98x

        May 12, 2017 02:22 PM

        He’s not hurting anyones development, he may be hurting their results and our (and the team’s) ability to evaluate his pitchers development.

        Inability to measure development doesn’t equal no development occurring.

    • Romus

      May 11, 2017 02:37 PM

      Agree with you….moving Rupp, would probably dictate bringing up a catcher with more defensive skills, since Knapp would at that point be given the bulk of the game appearances.
      Logan Moore is probably one of the more defensive catchers in the system and has been a good soldier for many years now. As for age , since you mention that both Joseph and Rupp are relatively young. Rupp will actually turn 29 in September, so he has some wear and tear on his body now, and counting his Texas days he has close to 800 total games catching…otoh, Joseph turns 26 later this season.

      • Patrick Bodner

        May 12, 2017 08:53 AM

        I too have faith in Tommy Joseph I think he’s going to be an All-Star someday hopefully sooner then ladder he’s going to be in the league with Mike Schmidt and Jim Thome. I Rupp seen his better days he is 289 yrs old we need a bat and he’s down there in the minors ready to come

      • Steve

        May 13, 2017 07:24 AM

        Wow thats bold. I dont necessarily disagree that Joseph could be a good everyday 1b, and maybe even an allstar once or twice, but 500 hr?

  2. Better Safe Than Sorry

    May 11, 2017 03:12 PM

    Can’t think of a single good reason, besides satisfying antsy fans, to bring up Hoskins & Alfaro immediately. If they are legit, they’ll be legit in sept, too. Downside of rushing a guy far outweighs any real benefit

  3. Patrick Bodner

    May 12, 2017 08:49 AM

    I too have faith in Tommy Joseph I think he’s going to be an All-Star someday hopefully sooner then ladder he’s going to be in the league with Mike Schmidt and Jim Thome

    • 64survivor

      May 12, 2017 01:10 PM

      Patrick…later not ladder

    • denzen

      May 12, 2017 05:57 PM

      Hope you are right, but I don’t see it happening. He turns 26 soon, and I don’t see anything in his past that says star at 1st. Hope he gets hot so they can trade him and Rupp.

Next ArticleCrash Bag Vol. 19: Rapid Fire Answers