2016 Phillies Report Card: Tyler Goeddel

Tyler Goeddel was at a bit of a disadvantage in 2016. The 23-year old outfielder was plucked from the Tampa Bay Rays’ farm system as the first pick in the Rule 5 draft. The 2011 first round pick rose through the Rays system as a third baseman, but was converted to the outfield in 2015. His strong arm made him a fit for right field.

Throughout the Minors, Goeddel had above-average speed and roughly average power, and had the strongest season of his prospect career in 2015. That year, he produced the best strikeout and power numbers of his career to-date, while racking up his fourth straight 20+ stolen base season. He was seen as one of the most polished batters available in the Rule 5 draft, and in a rare move, was confirmed to be the Phillies’ top overall selection days in advance.

Goeddel’s disadvantage from the jump in 2016 was two-fold. The primary disadvantage he faced was inherent to being a Rule 5 pick – by definition, these inexperienced players are required to stick on the Major League roster all season, and unlike other struggling players, cannot receive further seasoning in the Minors. Most of these players fail, and are returned to their original team.

His secondary disadvantage was specific to Philadelphia’s recent success in the Rule 5 draft. Goeddel spent the 2016 season in the shadow of Odubel Herrera‘s massive success only a year earlier, and beyond that, the Phillies’ success at selecting athletic, disciplined outfielders in the Rule 5 draft (Shane Victorino, Ender Inciarte, and Herrera were all selected in an eleven year stretch and have produced 48.5 combined fWAR since their drafts). Expectations were probably unreasonable from day 1.

In 2016, the Phillies clearly watched a player that was over matched at the plate. Outside of an impressive May (113 wRC+), Goeddel’s bat was not Major League-ready. His power numbers (.099 ISO) dipped from his prior levels, and he hit 53.8 percent of batted balls on the ground. His soft-hit rate was one of the highest in the Majors. Not all of these struggles should be laid at his feet – he was used intermittently throughout the year (Goeddel totaled only 213 plate appearances in 92 games), and this lack of use may have had a hand in his struggle to adapt. Defensive metrics didn’t love him, but they’re also unusable over such a small sample. He was, however, the impetus for the most exciting moment of the Phillies’ season.

Short of a miraculous Spring Training, I’m confident that Goeddel will begin the 2017 season in Triple-A Lehigh Valley. He struggled mightily in his Major League debut, but with a team that was both unable to send him to the Minors and unwilling to play him everyday, he was in a less-than-ideal situation. The decline in his strikeout and walk rates were not as bad as they could have been, and he still may have some kind of a future in the Majors.

In 2016, Tyler Goeddel looked like exactly what he was – a player plucked from Double-A and forced into a full Major League season. His line by itself warrants one of the lowest grades of the season, but considering the cards he was dealt, came in a little below reasonable expectations.

Grade: C-

Leave a Reply


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


  1. Sam

    November 29, 2016 12:49 PM

    TG was that rare major league hitter that regularly has fastballs blown by him/make weak contact. Granted he has a natural oppo stroke, but still. If you can’t catch up to heat, you’re not a major leaguer as that’s job 1.

    • Romus

      November 29, 2016 04:37 PM

      Perhaps he will gain strength in this off-season and will get more experience at the AAA level.
      Matt Klentak’s last Rule 5 project from the Angels…Taylor Featherston….followed that path.
      Unfortunately, he is not with the org anymore.

  2. Rogers Hornsby

    November 29, 2016 05:00 PM

    He was Grossly mismanaged. He bats 279 in 22 games in May, gets benched. Give us all a Break!

    • Andrew R.

      November 29, 2016 05:55 PM

      Well, we can all agree he had a decent month when he played. He missed out in opportunities to whom? Cody Asche, Aaron Altherr, etc.,. I just don’t know why he didn’t get to play a little bit more. It’s not like he was hurting our playoff chances. Experience would’ve only made him better and work harder when he’s in triple-A next year.

      I think if he had more chances and a little more success, it would’ve benefitted him for 2017. He would be in triple-A mentoring the kids, telling them how great it was, working his tail off to fix his deficiencies. But now, what are his deficiencies? He couldn’t hit mlb pitching. He might be down there pressing to not just hit minor league pitching, but crush it. Maybe he thinks he’ll have to hit phenomenally for the organization to take him seriously and call him up. He’ll be 24? 25? next year? He knows his clock is ticking.

  3. Major Malfunction

    December 01, 2016 01:32 PM

    Goeddell looks like if you give him a few sandwiches and AAA playing time, he could be another Victorino type player. He appears to be scrappy and plays balls out. If he can improve his contact, he looks like he has natural athletic talent to produce results.

  4. Just Bob

    December 04, 2016 03:26 AM

    Another guy who had a decent offensive stretch over a few weeks and several highlight defensive plays. Overall his defense was poor & didn’t make adjustments to pitchers throwing him inside almost all year.

    Corner OFs who are subpar defensively, can’t play CF, and don’t hit for power don’t have much value at the MLB level.

    Maybe he manages manages to improve a bit defensively but he strikes me as a ‘AAAA’/5th OF. He isn’t that young either. Already 24 and he is getting close to non-prospect territory.


Next Article2016 Phillies Report Card: Peter Bourjos