Tommy The Usurper

For the first time in almost 11 years, Ryan Howard is not the Phillies’ everyday first baseman. What did it take to supplant the former National League Rookie of the Year, Most Valuable Player, and World Series champ?

It took a former second round pick drafted out of high school in Scottsdale, Arizona. It took a prospect originally acquired in the 2012 trade that sent Hunter Pence to San Francisco. It took a Triple-A performance from a catcher-turned first baseman that the big league club couldn’t ignore. It took Tommy Joseph.

Even given Howard’s vile 2016 performance—his .150 batting average is worst of any major leaguer with 100 plate appearances—there was reason to not rush Joseph into a starting role. An injury-plagued minor league career saw Joseph appear in just 176 games (671 plate appearances) in the Phillies organization between August 2012 and May 2016, when he was called up to the bigs. His experience in the minors fell far short of what one would normally expect from a 24-year-old career minor leaguer.

Howard’s central role in bringing this city, and the Phils’ franchise, its first championship in 28 years complicated matters as well. Ignoring the awkward circumstance surrounding the man whose job he was looking to swipe, Joseph hit .286 through his first 48 plate appearances in what can only marginally be described as a platoon split, forcing Pete Mackanin to hold Howard out of the starting lineup for an extended weekend series in early June.

“It’s about seeing the younger guy who tore it up in Triple-A and came up here to make a good first impression,” Mackanin told reporters. “We want to get a look at him. As we know, this season is about the future. We’re in the middle of a rebuilding process.”

And a look is exactly what they got. Joseph kept on rolling, going seven-for-16 with two long balls in the next four games after his skipper’s announcement.

That hot streak, combined with Howard’s .101/.160/.261 month of May, the worst in franchise history, forced his manager’s hand. On Friday, Joseph learned he had earned the everyday starting job, appropriately celebrating with two more homers to bring his total to seven on the year.

Through 23 major league games, Joseph has made 77 plate appearances, so his numbers are most definitely subject to sample size disclaimers. But he’s brought power to a punchless offense and done so in emphatic fashion.

Entering the weekend, Joseph led all qualified rookies in wRC+ (163), wOBA (.416) and slugging percentage (.677).

Were Joseph to keep mashing at the pace in which he entered this weekend, his .677 slugging percentage would have ranked as the second-highest in a rookie campaign in the history of the game, behind only Levi Meyerle in 1871, the inaugural season of the country’s first ever professional baseball league. In the interest of transparency, Meyerle, a member of the Philadelphia Athletics, led the National Association in every triple slash category during that 28-game season (.492/.500/.700) in which the A’s scored over 13 runs per game. In the 28 games since Joseph’s call up, the Phillies have averaged 3.1 runs.

Again, Joseph’s 77 plate appearances rank 25th out of 29 qualified rookies. He hasn’t played upwards of 50 games like Corey Seager, Trevor Story or Nomar Mazara, but his hot start is not to be ignored. After all, it has already done the impossible: seizing the throne from Howard, who occupied the position for over a decade.

Since his major league debut, only 16 hitters have launched more homers than Joseph’s seven. All have done so in triple-digit plate appearances, Joseph has just 77. In that span, Joseph’s .616 slugging percentage ranks 17th of 271 hitters.

Again, Joseph needs more than four-and-a-half times his current major league at-bat total before his slugging percentage can be expected to stabilize. But since being called up, he leads the Phillies in batting average, slugging percentage and OPS, while hitting three more homers than any teammate.

It’s clear that Joseph has picked up right where he left off in Triple-A. When plucked from the minors, he led the International League in both batting average, .347, and OPS, .981. It was by far the hottest, most consistent streak of his career.

“I had a really good week once,” he jokingly told reporters, referring to a 15-for-32 stretch in Single-A San Jose in June 2011.

His efforts thus far have catapulted him atop the National League rookie leaderboards.

Screen Shot 2016-06-13 at 12.38.00 PM

Two things have stood out most thus far in Joseph’s fiery start: his dominance against lefties and his gap-to-gap power. Among NL hitters with at least 20 plate appearances against southpaws, only one hits at a higher clip than Joseph’s .421.

Now take a look at the spray chart of his hits thus far:

Spray Chart

Twenty of his 22 hits have come between the left and right field gaps. On the only two that didn’t, Joseph turned on low fastballs (91 mph from Wei-Yin Chen and 95 mph from Felipe Rivero) and deposited them into the seats down the left field line.

The biggest and likely only concern with Joseph thus far is his miniscule walk rate, a recurring trend throughout his minor league tenure. He’s worked just two walks in 77 plate appearances (2.6%), less that half the rate at which he drew free passes over his first five years in the minors (5.8%).

But despite the shortage of walks, Joseph has shown promise and has proved he’s learning how to attack pitchers. His batting average jumps from .222 to .353 to .467 during his first, second and third time facing an opposing starter.Screen Shot 2016-06-13 at 12.39.24 PM

He gets himself into some trouble when he offers at balls out of the zone, hitting .111 and slugging .222, but excels when putting strikes in play (.413 batting average, .848 slugging). His exit velocity by pitch location tells a similar story.

The major stepping-stone for Joseph will be whether he can limit his swings on balls he can’t effectively square up and, in the process, increase his pitch recognition and walk rate. If that were to happen, the Phils could once again have a powerful Rookie of the Year-caliber slugger manning first base for years to come.

Leave a Reply


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


  1. Romus

    June 13, 2016 02:51 PM

    Great write-up.
    Looking back after the ’09 draft…he signed late in August , then went to the Giants fall instructs in Arizona.
    But what is interesting….they put him straight in low A as his first pro assignment…as an 18-year old..catcher no less. Then the following year in hi-A at 19 and then AA at 20 and then the trade to the Phillies later that year.
    And his first 1500 PAs in the minors he hit approx. 50 HRs, after hitting 15 HRs in almost. 100 PAs in his senior year in HS and batting .494.
    The guy can flat out hit with power….if the catching responsibilities early on and concussions were not there to slow him down….no telling where his bat would have gone.

  2. smittyboy

    June 13, 2016 05:48 PM

    With all due respect to the quantifiable data you present his performance to date makes for a wonderful story – a former prospect making good after suffering multiple injuries and dismissed as being only a marginal player, at best. Moreover, the kid actually approaches the plate with a sense of purpose, patience, and he does hit the ball hard. He has not, yet – looked over matched. Kudos to him and the great little story within the rebuilding theme. Thanks for your spotlight on Mr. Joseph.

  3. Ryan

    June 14, 2016 09:15 AM

    I hope that he can continue to adjust to the challenges that going through the league multiple times represents. It’s a fantastic story and Tommy Boy couldn’t be more deserving.

  4. Ryan

    June 14, 2016 09:17 AM

    ToJo? Tommy Boy? It’s a great story. I hope that he can continue to make adjustments as the league will surely adjust to him much like it did to Howard although it appears that he sprays the ball a lot more and won’t be so adversely impacted by the shift.

  5. GB

    June 15, 2016 04:28 PM

    I’d argue it took a combination of Howard’s final contract year and the Phillies finally committing fully to their rebuild to replace Howard as the 1B.

    Tommy Joseph has done all he can to make his case, but it would not have mattered IMO unless the two above things were in play. Until now, the Phillies were stuck in a spiral of their own making – they were not going to replace Howard unless someone forced them to and that approach guaranteed no one ever would since the only way they could was by playing here at 1B regularly enough to show something meaningful.

    The Phillies could certainly have done this last season, but were not ready as it was made clear when Sandberg dared to bench Howard and upper management slapped him back into line. They could have even considered this the year before last, but again they were still in rebuild denial mode.

    The Phillies & Howard now should take the final step: come to agreement on his release this season so Howard can go find another team who wants to play him and the Phillies can give Joseph and anyone else they want shots at the position. Like all the other positions, it would finally be fun to have an actual open & fair competition at 1B and see which young talent can grab it.

    That, however, remains a bridge too far for both the Phillies and Howard unfortunately. Baby steps, as Richard Dreyfuss would say.

Next ArticleI Didn't Know We Had Zac Efron (It's Zach Eflin, Mom)