Utley Retrospective: The Return

In a lot of ways, the 2012 season was the beginning of the end for the Phillies’ short-lived “dynasty.” In the aftermath of a 102-win season, the Phillies limped into 2012 – so to speak – without Ryan Howard, Roy Oswalt, Raul Ibanez or Ryan Madson, and the downturns of players like Roy Halladay were only a breath away. What’s more, they were christening the start of another season without Chase Utley, whose knees were once more betraying him.

The start was an inauspicious as could be predicted: the Phils found themselves at 36-40 and in fourth in the NL East, dangling over the precipice of last place by a thread just half-a-game thick. It wasn’t pretty, and the outlook wasn’t exactly gleaming. And yet, on June 27, Utley made his return, and it felt like the hope of contention was nearly back within the Phils’ grasp. How could it not? Utley, who had battled patellar tendonitis and Chondromalacia patella at least as far back as 2010, stood to deliver more than the ragtag quadruped of Freddy Galvis, Michael Martinez, Pete Orr and Mike Fontenot had provided to that point.

And so it was that on June 27, Utley’s name was reinserted into the lineup, batting third, playing second base, like an early trade acquisition with the added bonus of coming prepackaged as a beloved team icon. A throng of more than 44,000 packed Citizens Bank Park, their ears ready to take in the intro guitar lick to Led Zeppelin’s “Kashmir” for the first time all over again. The TV broadcast opened with a welcoming highlight package, heralding the return of the player we had all so sorely missed. Nothing could go wrong on this day.

As Utley came to the plate with none on and two out in the bottom of the first, he was met with the sort of ovation reserved for sports heroes; the kind you can feel through your television, the kind that is powered by claps with the added ferocity of being fueled by memory. “Nostalgia” is becoming a trite word anymore, but in its purest sense, that’s kind of what we all felt as we saw Utley walk to the plate, whether live that night or in a highlight down the road. Sure, the team was still technically in a competitive window, but the malaise and the humbling nature of the losing that had occurred so soon after a fifth straight playoff run made the feeling of remembering what it was like to win – just four short seasons ago – feel that much more powerful.

Utley could have struck out. That would have been fine. A ball in play would have been cool and, maybe, if we wanted to be greedy, we could hope for it to fall for a base hit. As it turns out, we were afforded a luxury. Utley took a 2-2 curveball from James McDonald out to far right-center, many rows deep into section 102. It was an authoritative home run, and in true Utley fashion, the most emotion in the whole process was arguably shown in the force with which he slapped the hands of his teammates upon his arrival in the dugout. Everything about it was Utley, from that high-fiving all the back to his slamming a mistake pitch to a power alley. It was Chase, and he was back.

Leave a Reply


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


  1. Tim

    August 21, 2015 12:52 PM

    Well, after thoroughly evaluating the likely NL playoff teams, Pittsburgh is my clear rooting interest to win the pennant, which is fine. Aside from them though, I’m afraid I’ll have to be rooting for the fucking Dodgers now for the sake of Jimmy and Chase. LOOK WHAT YOU MADE ME DO, NATIONAL LEAGUE!

  2. Chris S.

    August 21, 2015 03:25 PM

    I remember sitting down to watch that game and after Chase hit the HR I thought now we are on track to make it back to the post season… Great Chase Utley moment, but ultimately that year was the beginning of the end.

  3. JustBob

    August 24, 2015 03:51 PM

    How is it really nostalgia during his first game in ’10? Not quite the word or feeling I would have used to describe it.

    More like buoyant or hopeful that with Utley (and Halladay due back sometime right after the ASB) they were about to begin another second half surge which would take them back to the playoffs as he happened for the previous 5 years.

    Instead they continued to scuffle in July, got swept a few times in mid-July, and wound up as sellers trading Vic, Pence, and Blanton.

Next ArticleUtley Retrospective - The Minors and Rookie Campaign(s)