Phillies Will Lack Plate Discipline in 2013

From 2006-10, a five-year span, the Phillies laid claim to one of the most prolific offenses in Major League Baseball. Behind one of baseball’s youngest, most-talented cores — Chase Utley, Ryan Howard, Jimmy Rollins, and Jayson Werth — the Phillies did it all: they hit for average, they hit for power, they drew a lot of walks, and they ran the bases often and efficiently. Offense across baseball began to decline in 2010, but the Phillies declined much more sharply as that once-young core succumbed to older age and injury woes.

The Phillies finished in MLB’s top-ten in walk rate in five of six seasons between 2006-11, the outlier being 2009 when they finished eleventh. In 2012, they finished 26th in walk rate.

Year BB% MLB Rank
2006 9.6% 5
2007 9.8% 3
2008 9.3% 8
2009 9.3% 11
2010 8.9% 8
2011 8.6% 9
2012 7.4% 26

Injuries played a big role in that decline. Consider the injured players and their replacements.

Howard and Ruiz’s walk rates were also under their typical rates, 12.0 percent and 10.4 percent, respectively, so the baseline for comparison was even lower than it should have been.

Although Utley, Howard, and Ruiz will be healthy, the Phillies aren’t expected to improve much in the walks department. ZiPS projects only two Phillies to finish with a double-digit walk rate: Utley and Howard, and just barely at 10.4 and 10.1 percent, respectively. Lower the threshold to nine percent and only Ruiz joins the party. Domonic Brown just misses the cut at 8.9 percent. The off-season additions of Michael Young (projected 5.8%), Ben Revere (5.2%), and Delmon Young (3.6%) don’t exactly help matters.

Walks, of course, are a big part of on-base percentage, and on-base percentage is heavily positively correlated with run-scoring. The Phillies finished ninth in on-base percentage last season and would have been much worse if not for the fluky-high batting averages of Frandsen (.338), Ruiz (.325), and Juan Pierre (.307). PECOTA projects the Phillies to finish with the fourth-worst OBP in the National League in 2013, and subsequently the third-fewest runs scored.

As a result, the Phillies will be depending on their pitching to win a plethora of low-scoring affairs in 2013. Behind two perennial Cy Young candidates in Cole Hamels and Cliff Lee and one of baseball’s most dominant closers in Jonathan Papelbon, that may not be such a bad idea. Indeed, PECOTA projects the pitching staff to allow the fourth-fewest runs in the league. However, a lot is riding on the good health of Roy Halladay and Mike Adams, and better-than-expected performance from the back of the rotation and bullpen. The Phillies don’t have any margin for error as they did a few years ago when a playoff berth was all but guaranteed.

Leave a Reply



  1. LTG

    February 20, 2013 06:02 PM

    RE: Causation in Power Hitters and Walks

    The causal relationship is reciprocal. Power hitters have good pitch recognition and hand-eye coordination, which allows them to pick out good pitches to drive. Even Howard, the much maligned, has had good plate discipline for most of his career. This talent is also good for taking walks when they are proffered. Conversely, pitchers try to avoid power hitters happy zones and this can lead to walks as well. So, a power hitters power is produced, in part, by a talent that tends to produce walks, and a power hitters walks are produced, in part, by a talent that tends to produce HRs.

    Here’s an interesting 2012 leaderboard:,d

    Notice where Ryan Howard isn’t.

  2. Phillie697

    February 20, 2013 06:13 PM


    Could be because Ryan Howard didn’t accumulate enough at-bats to be on that list ๐Ÿ™‚ If he did, he’s 37.0% O-Swing rate would have 23rd on that list ๐Ÿ™‚

  3. LTG

    February 20, 2013 06:36 PM

    I thought Pitch f/x had him at 32?

  4. Phillie697

    February 20, 2013 08:31 PM


    Well, immediately above the Pitch f/x, it says 37% in the regular “Plate Discipline” section for Howard.

    As for Douchbag Young, there is a reason why he doesn’t walk.

    Man, my brain must not be working today. I can see from my posts today that I wrote like I’m in elementary school.

  5. LTG

    February 20, 2013 10:20 PM

    I take pitch f/x to be more accurate.

  6. cb

    February 22, 2013 08:23 AM

    Your conclusion that the Phillies will be relying on pitching to win low-scoring battles doesn’t necessarily follow from the premises you seek to establish, Bill. If Domonic Brown improves at a level consistent with natural development, Howard returns to his pre-injury level, and Utley plays a full season with no further physical deterioration, production should be up significantly from last year, even factoring in the drop in production expected at catcher.

Next ArticleFinding the Next Pierre and Frandsen