Phillies Top Prospect Odyssey: Primer

You people love lists and rankings. It’s why Bleacher Report has become the McDonalds of sports blogs. It’s why Forbes has as many slideshows on their website as they do actual business news and I bet you can you can guess which Maxim issue sells the most copies each year. Prospect lists are no different. These lists garner clickage with extreme prejudice. While they’re often misleading and almost immediately obsolete, top prospect lists are actually footed in reality. Major League organizations have their own lists on hand (and look at lists compiled by the more respected outlets to see how the industry perceives certain players) should a situation arise in which rapid decision making is of the essence. It is for this reason that I recently considered compiling such a list for Crashburn Alley. You probably want a list, and the legitimacy of such rankings combined with the eyes it would bring to Bill’s site leave it too enticing to pass up. So I’ll be doing a list of yet-to-be-determined length.

But I’m going to do it the right way, a way that provides you with a bevy of information and opinion about the Phillies farm system from several people whose careers are dedicated to pondering such issues.

Over the next several weeks I hope to bring you conversations with some of the industry’s most esteemed independent talent evaluators and information hubs. Voices from Baseball America, Baseball Prospectus, and our mothership at ESPN are all actively engaging with me about participating in this activity. We will discuss the author’s top 10 (or 20 or 30 or however many) Phillies prospects, the methods they used to compile this list, the individuals that lie therein as well as some other aspects of the organization. I want to use this little, inconsequential late night post to act as a little primer (which it has) and, eventually, a convenient hub that will house links to all of these discussions in one location.


Jason Parks of Baseball Prospectus

Jim Callis of Baseball America

Hudson Belinsky of Lindy’s Phillies Annual

Keith Law of ESPN

Jonathan Mayo of

Leave a Reply



  1. nik

    January 15, 2013 11:03 PM

    Thanks Eric, really looking forward to it.

  2. BradInDC

    January 15, 2013 11:05 PM

    Woo. In all seriousness, “Woo”.


  3. Jeff P

    January 15, 2013 11:10 PM

    Nice stuff man, definitely excited to hear what you can pull together from all these guys.

Next ArticleChase Utley and Left-Handed Pitching