Chase Utley: Public Enemy Number One

For a long time, Chase Utley has been beloved in Philadelphia. Although he’s not much of a talker, he’s had quite a few iconic moments as a Phillie for what he’s said and done, baseball talent aside. Remember the 2008 All-Star Game where he was booed by New York fans? Or his great speech in Citizens Bank Park during the team’s victory parade? Utley may have been Harry Kalas’ favorite player this side of Michael Jack Schmidt, once exclaimingChase Utley, you are the man!” when he scored on an infield single. How about Utley’s historically great defensive play to nail Jason Bartlett at home plate in Game 5 of the ’08 World Series? Or his flipping the ball back with understated attitude, causing the benches to clear, after Jonathan Sanchez hit him with a pitch in Game Six of the NLCS?

Let Mac from the TV show It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia sum up the love for Utley:

Unfortunately, the Phillies lost the NLCS to the Giants in six games, thanks in part to Utley’s .182/.333/.227 triple-slash line and multiple defensive miscues. Combine that with a career-low offensive output in the regular season which included a thumb injury that caused him to spend 49 days on the disabled list, the love for Utley is starting to dissipate.

The recency effect and Utley’s understated personality are causing people to forget about his elite production both offensively and defensively. Earlier this year, I made the case that Utley is, by far, the best defensive second baseman in baseball. Even factoring in his poor defensive showing in the post-season, I stand by that.

The various Sabermetric defensive stats tend to disagree with each other much more frequently than their offensive counterparts, but the one thing they do agree on is that Utley is an elite defender. Over the last three seasons, no one has a higher UZR/150 than Utley. He is second to Mark Ellis in Revised Zone Rating (RZR) .862 to .842, has made the most Out Of Zone plays (OOZ) with 137, and racked up the most Defensive Runs Saved (DRS), nearly doubling the second-highest total of Ellis, 60 to 33.

Offensively, over the past three seasons, Utley has the highest wOBA at .391, 18 points ahead of runner-up Dustin Pedroia. He has the third-highest speed score at 6.0, trailing Ian Kinsler and Brian Roberts.

Despite Utley’s place atop baseball as the best second baseman and arguably the second-most valuable player at any position, he is being bandied about in trade rumors. His down year in 2010 is being used as evidence of decline, the small sample of at-bats and defensive opportunities in the post-season as reason for the Phillies to shake things up, change the culture, and get back to the organization’s winning ways.

Leading the charge is radio host Mike Missanelli of 97.5 The Fanatic. You may remember Missanelli from his shouting match with Keith Law when the two were debating the merits of the large Ryan Howard contract extension. While I’m confident that he was trying to drive up the station’s listenership based on his previous actions and his reputation, his words do have a ripple effect in the baseball community. Some people actually view him as an authority in baseball analysis and will take his thoughts seriously.

I want to stifle the “trade Utley” crowd before it ever becomes a crowd. I’m overreacting to one madman, but I’ve seen the way irrational sentiment can sweep through Philadelphia and it is not pretty. It is ludicrous to consider trading Utley for a multitude of reasons, just as it was ludicrous to hand Howard a $125 million contract extension. As mentioned above, Utley is a rare breed of player, arguably the second-most valuable player in baseball. If Utley’s gone, who replaces him? Do you move Placido Polanco to second and sign a free agent third baseman like Adrian Beltre?

The Phillies have Utley under contract for three more years at $15 million apiece, decidedly below market value. Polanco will be in town for two more seasons and possibly a third if the Phillies are content with his level of production at the time. How much would it take to sign Beltre? Multiple years, and considering the type of season he had with the Boston Red Sox in 2010, the Phillies should probably expect to shell out upwards of $30 million. And that’s assuming that the Phillies can sign Beltre — they’ll have competition for the third baseman’s services, of course.

Additionally, the Phillies would be buying high on Beltre and selling low on Utley, two things that should be avoided in any walk of life. It would make more sense to trade Utley after, say, his 2008 season when he had a .915 OPS and had won a World Series. While Utley’s actual value may not have been drastically different, the perception of his value would have been. How much value would the Phillies be able to get out of Utley following a career-worst offensive season in which he was injured and ineffective in the post-season? And from whom could they get that value? While any team should jump at the chance to acquire Utley, the remaining $45 million on his contract is a burden on some teams, thus reducing his trade value even further. Other teams already have second basemen, and other teams consider themselves too out-of-the-picture to jump in the conversation.

Are the Phillies going to trade Utley? No. Absolutely not. But this wasn’t a response to the possibility of the trade, but to the environment that allows these ridiculous rumors to propagate. Philadelphia has run some athletes out of town and scared off potential free agent signings (Yankees fans may prevent a Cliff Lee signing, by the way). During the depression circa 1995-2002, that was somewhat understandable. On the heels of four consecutive NL East titles and one world championship, there is no need to be so irrational and reactionary.

The Phillies, and Chase, are fine.

Leave a Reply


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


  1. ron Cornwall

    October 29, 2010 05:54 PM

    me too. but he’s at .832 this year. hurt schmurt. he’s dinged every year… the same as everyone else. these numbers are cross sections of his plate appearances that project over 162 the same way… i’m not even getting into his power numbers. his doubles, hrs, and slugging are trending down the same way.

    i think a more accurate comparison would be with a 2nd baseman that has also not won multiple mvp trophies… someone like richie weeks, dan uggla or robinson cano. chase falls somewhere between them.

  2. Scott G

    October 29, 2010 06:03 PM

    Unbelievable. You’re basing this stuff off of subjective voting? You do realize that Utley was more valuable in 2007 when Jimmy Rollins won the MVP?

    Votto, Pujols, CarGo, and Tulo all can’t win the MVP this year. At least three of them “suck” for not being better, right?

  3. ron Cornwall

    October 30, 2010 04:28 AM

    scott g
    you missed the point. pujols is an unfit comparison as chase has not won multiple mvp awards and is a second baseman.
    don’t be dense to defend your holey argument.

  4. Scott G

    October 30, 2010 12:25 PM

    Using Pujols was a joke (hence the lol). You cited Chase’s declining OPS numbers. .976 is pretty lofty and probably could not be sustained. The next two seasons his OPSes were almost equal. This year they were likely down because of injury. He played out of his mind in 07, played almost identically in 08 and 09, and then played injured in 10. I wouldn’t say he’s declining. I’d say his 08 and 09 numbers are what you should expect.

    You also used an MVP award as a barometer of how good a player is. I don’t think I should need to explain to you why that is flawed.

  5. hk

    October 30, 2010 01:14 PM

    ron Cornwall: “he’s dinged every year… the same as everyone else. these numbers are cross sections of his plate appearances that project over 162 the same way… i’m not even getting into his power numbers. his doubles, hrs, and slugging are trending down the same way.”

    In a year where he came back early from an injured thumb, Utley produced a.373 wOBA, good enough to tie him for 28th in MLB with Hanley Ramirez and Joe Mauer and place him 1st among Phillies expected to return in 2011. If the FO is stupid enough to trade Utley and not resign Werth, the 2011 season will make the 2010 post-season look like an offensive explosion by comparison.

Next ArticleOne More Note on Chase Utley