Game Four was a microcosm of the Phillies’ 2009 season. Starter not named Cliff Lee gives up too many runs in too few innings, middle relief does a decent job of keeping the game close, the Phillies catch up, Brad Lidge wraps the game up with a nice bow tie for the opposition.

Eleven blown saves. At least one run allowed in 30 of his 67 appearances during the regular season.

The fear that came along with Charlie Manuel’s continuing to rely on Lidge was that their 2008 untouchable superstar would come in in a critical spot in the playoffs and — well, you know the rest. That fear came to fruition tonight, even after Lidge rather handily retired the first two Yankees in the top of the ninth inning.

Johnny Damon had what is known as a “professional at-bat” when he fouled off five Brad Lidge offerings to work the count to 3-2 after eight pitches. On the ninth, he hit a line drive that dropped in front of left fielder Raul Ibanez for the single. What would unfold next is atypical, but given Lidge’s season, perhaps not surprising.

With the right-hander on the mound, Mark Teixeira came up to the plate in the left-handed batter’s box. Due to that, the Phillies shifted their infield towards the right side, leaving Pedro Feliz at shortstop and covering second base on a stolen base attempt. Damon attempted and succeeded to steal the base, and because Lidge failed to cover third base with the shifted infield, Damon dashed past Feliz for the free extra base.

Still, a runner on third base with two outs is not terrible news — it just means that Carlos Ruiz has to be sharp on Lidge’s slider in the dirt. And that is perhaps why Lidge was victimized, as he hit Teixeira to put runners on the corners for Alex Rodriguez. He then threw a first-pitch low-and-inside fastball to get ahead of A-Rod.

Perhaps Rodriguez was looking for another fastball because he knew that the slider was less of an option with the runner on third base. Nonetheless, Lidge threw another fastball and it was laced past Ibanez in left field for a go-ahead RBI double.

The Yankees would tack on two more runs when Lidge threw four fastballs out of five pitches to Jorge Posada. The fourth fastball was lined into the left-center field gap, scoring Teixeira and Rodriguez to up the score to 7-4. Posada was thrown out trying to advance to second base.

It is a devastating loss for the Phillies as they once again showed their resilience when Pedro Feliz hit a game-tying solo home run in the bottom of the eighth off of Joba Chamberlain. That hit would have been added to Ryan Howard’s go-ahead double in Colorado and Jimmy Rollins’ walk off against the Dodgers’ Jonathan Broxton, but it went for naught. Chase Utley’s dominance against C.C. Sabathia is also lost as a result of Lidge’s ninth inning collapse.

The Phillies now find themselves down three games to one with three games left to play, all of which they must win if they want to repeat as World Series champions.

Game graph above courtesy FanGraphs.

Leave a Reply


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


  1. J

    November 02, 2009 03:55 PM

    Chucky P – “Regular rest” is 4 days off in between starts. Pettite started on Saturday night, so with his next start on Wednesday, that would only be 3 days of rest (Sunday, Monday, Tuesday).

  2. Chinner

    November 02, 2009 04:55 PM

    By J on Nov 2, 2009

    If the game is at night (which it is, 7:57pm EST) you can pretty much count wednesday as a day of rest. I think that is what Chucky P was referring to.

    Two great teams, already better than last years series.

  3. Pete

    November 02, 2009 08:35 PM

    Thank you Daniel. I appreciate your analysis of ARod being hit by pitches.

    And I certainly agree Bob that intentionally trying to injure a player should not be a part of baseball. But pitching inside and even hitting players IS a part of baseball and ALWAYS has been. Admittedly, it is declining in recent years, so maybe a softer sensibility is winning out. But it also seems it would be much more difficult to explain steroid use and the other things you mentioned than hitting a batter with pitches. Just check out Daniel’s explanation above for how easy it is to explain correctly.

    And finally, I hope seeing ARod hit on the arm, leg and ribs does not scar or influence children too much. Otherwise, what do we do and how do we explain a take-out slide at second or a collision at home plate? Actually, maybe getting hit by a pitch or standing in against a runner is a good lesson for kids; certainly could make the argument that it is a good way to break kids in for the much rougher treatment life often has in store for us.

Next ArticleA Harrowing Escape