Can Madson Close, Please?

Ryan MadsonBrad Lidge blew his second straight opportunity in a row and sixth of the season in 19 opportunities. After saving five in a row, including three against the 14-39 Nationals and one against the Padres’ 29th-best offense in the Majors, everyone thought he was healed, but he’s continued to pitch terribly as the season has progressed. His 7.20 ERA heading into the game was scary, and his 5.90 FIP doesn’t make you feel any better.

Nearly a month ago, I suggested putting Lidge on the 15-day disabled list and transitioning Madson into the closer’s role. Two weeks ago, I made the same suggestion. Today, I’m stating it again: Let Madson close. There’s no reason not to make the move.

The Phillies were lucky to be 11 games above .500 going into today’s game with the Dodgers, considering that 10 of their 32 wins are against the absolutely terrible Nationals team. Without the Nats, the Phils would be 22-19. The schedule doesn’t get any easier as the Phillies are scheduled to play the Mets, Red Sox, and Blue Jays in the next two weeks.

They can’t afford to give away games to good teams the way they did last night to the Dodgers. Even if they’re supposedly playing with house money, they can’t afford it. It’s time to take this season seriously and demote Lidge out of the closer’s role and promote Madson.

Update: The Phillies lose in twelve innings on an Andre Ethier walk-off hit for the second-straight night. This time it was a home run off of Chad Durbin. That’s three more innings the bullpen shouldn’t have had to pitch thanks to Lidge.

Leave a Reply


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


  1. Eh

    June 06, 2009 11:51 PM

    Loyalty to vets. Same reason why orlando cabrera still leads off, and he is the worst player in baseball.

    Lidge was never a great closer, he just had a great year last year. Looks like the Fairy Dust has worn off.

    “Last year’s last year and this year’s this year,” Phillies manager Charlie Manuel said. “He’s got the same stuff he had last year, but that’s baseball. Right when you think you’ve got this game whipped, it can jump right up and bite you. But he’ll always be my guy. If you do something else with him, I think that could hurt his confidence.”

  2. Eh

    June 06, 2009 11:53 PM

    Also, its fairly entertaining he’s worried about his confidence, yet the team isn’t where they should be with the mets injured and braves still figuring it out.

    Games in May and June mean the same as games in September.

    There may be a lot of unhappy philly fans come september.

  3. MikeS

    June 07, 2009 07:40 PM

    I’m trying to convince myself that Lidge has just been suffering from bad luck, and that his luck is sure to improve.

Next ArticleBDD: What's Wrong with Jimmy?